Press
Student arrested by police after stalker made false harassment claims
Images
Jodie Morrow had just finished an early shift at her cafe job in December 2020 when she noticed missed calls from the police on her phone. She knew this would have something to do with Ezra Garfield, the man who she told police had been plaguing her with messages on social media after they briefly dated. For three months beforehand, the Ulster University student had raised concerns about Garfield and, despite her repeated contact with officers, he had not been arrested. But an hour later it was now Jodie in the back of a police car, tearfully facing a journey to custody, having been arrested over false allegations that she was the one harassing him. More than five years later, Garfield was eventually jailed after pleading guilty to harassment and perverting the course of justice, and the Police Service of Northern Ireland has acknowledged "shortcomings" in how the case was handled. The 19-year-old was studying in Belfast in March 2020 when she matched with Garfield, who at the time was known as Riagain Grainger, on a popular dating app. A few months later the pair went on a handful of "lovely, wholesome" dates. "It was very normal initially… He seemed absolutely lovely at the start," she told BBC Radio Ulster's Good Morning Ulster programme. "He never had a single red flag at all." But Jodie felt "the spark wasn't there" and she was planning to let him down gently. When she told him she did not want to see him again, she said "he just completely switched". Jodie was then bombarded with missed calls and messages from two numbers purporting to be Garfield's mother and father, but she was sure he was behind it all. In September 2020 she reported the harassment to the police. The messages continued to come. She was added to Instagram group chats by people who said they were his friends. "I got sent a picture of him with what I was told was my name carved into his chest," she added. "You don't know how to process that at all, it was all a blur. "I kept thinking if I keep going to the police… It'll stop." Jodie made further police statements, as well as putting in a complaint with Ulster University, where the Trillick, County Tyrone, man had enrolled after meeting her. In December 2020, Garfield also went to the police claiming that Jodie was, in fact, the one harassing him. He had faked phone calls and threatening Instagram messages from her, but refused to hand his phone over to police. "It wasn't until they put me in the car and were explaining to me my rights that I realised I was getting arrested and it sort of all hit me," she said. "I was just so frustrated… I just can't believe they're taking his word on this." Garfield had yet to be arrested, but Jodie had been searched, fingerprinted, placed in a cell and, after interview, was released on bail. Her phone was seized for three months until tests showed Garfield had generated the calls from an app. In February 2022, Garfield - brought to trial under his previous name, Riagain Grainger - was jailed for two-and-a-half years after pleading guilty to a charge of stalking involving serious alarm and distress. The court heard he had stalked and bombarded a 21-year-old woman with messages in 2019 after meeting when the pair studied together in Manchester. Jodie had to then wait for her case to be heard, and in February of this year she was in court to see the 25-year-old jailed for 19 months, with a further 19 months on supervised licence on his release from prison. Jodie said the harassment was distressing, but it was the police process that made her ordeal worse. Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI) Assistant Chief Constable Ryan Henderson said it was a "complex investigation" and officers had "acted in good faith, and on the information available to them at the time". "It became clear that Garfield had intended to portray himself as a victim to make the real victim in this case look like an offender." He said officers have acknowledged the "shortcomings" in how Jodie's case was handled. "Throughout this case investigators worked with a number of police services across the UK in order to locate Garfield and bring him to justice before court," he added. Following a review, Jodie has agreed to work with the PSNI to improve their systems and practices. Jodie also said she feels let down by Ulster University and how they dealt with her complaint about Garfield's harassment. "In the end he got a slap on the wrist," she said. "He got banned from campus at a time when everything was online." An Ulster University spokesperson said: "Every student has a right to feel safe at university and at Ulster we work hard to create a safe, inclusive and respectful environment. "Harassment and stalking are not tolerated, we take seriously our safeguarding responsibilities and we are fully committed to treating all complaints sensitively and seriously." Jodie said the experience had changed her. "There's always an unconscious layer of it there. "It makes you feel quite isolated. He deliberately made it all quite disorienting. "No one should ever feel like they're the problem for being wrapped up in something like this, because of someone else." If you have been affected by any of the issues in this story, help and support is available at BBC Action Line. It is the 50th anniversary of a bomb attack that killed Willie Herron, his wife Beth and their daughter Noeline died in their drapery shop in Dromore in 1976. Hospitality business owners in Northern Ireland are calling for VAT to be lowered in line with the Republic of Ireland. The Education Authority says as of Tuesday morning about 80% of post-primary schools are back online. A health trust is withdrawing a care package that helped an 84-year-old man to look after his two sons. The suspect, 36, is being questioned on suspicion of four counts of attempted murder after the incident in Londonderry.